Subscribe to RSS

Friday, February 15th, 2013

Attention universities and colleges: Ready to be accountable ? The Feds question, period.

If properly implemented, Citizenship and Immigration Canada’s (CIC) “proposed changes to Canada’s International Student Program” projects to both curtail and police student visa abuse. The goal is to insure the integrity of the future of the student visa program. It may also scare the heck out of several Canadian universities and colleges. Why ? Because simply put, it proposes to make them accountable !

For years Canada’s universities and colleges have been handing out visa invitations around the world – that’s what an offer of admission amounts to in terms of entry to Canada. Very few institutions actually know for sure who they are admitting to Canada, and far too many openly engage with conduits to Canada which are highly unscrupulous. For those institutions, foreign students mean a lot of instant cash, even if there is significant abuse going on in with their help or in their name, and whether they know of it or not.

Give the Canadian government some credit here. They see what’s coming and don’t want just a tsunami alarm system, they want to prevent a big wave of visa abuse before it even hits Canadian shores. Australia and the United Kingdom have already been heavily damaged, and so much so that their federal governments are fed up, drastically reduced student visa opportunities to their countries. Foreign students head counts are way down in those nations, and now that gathering tide is looking for someplace else to land. This is what is building the momentum of the global student movement to Canada – and not that the world suddenly woke up and realized they want a quality Canadian education.

Sure Canada wants students, but supposedly it wants real students with genuine intentions to study. So the federal government is making it both easier and harder to come. It’s easier in terms of the new visa protocols and processing systems for applicants and potentially tougher in terms of identifying where the system is being abused and taking a strict stand against it.

Canada’s government proposes its academic institutions to be required to report on who comes to study and who does not. Citizenship and Immigration calls it “a back-end compliance mechanism to capture study permit compliance information.” The proposal adds that “institutions may also pro-actively identify students who don’t show up, or, CIC may initiate targeted requests.” The plans calls for a third-party technology mechanism, likely a web-based portal, to be set up for universities and colleges to report on status of their students and the government would analyze the data.

Basically this in some way regulates institutions to be responsible for international students they invite to Canada. This is where the squawking starts. When it comes to accountability, few institutions in society have as free a rein as universities and colleges. They have enormous operating budgets, relaxed demands on productivity, very little public and media scrutiny, and unlike politicians do not have to stand for re-election. In the past, calls by government to report on students’ status has been seen as a invasion of privacy. But then are institutions not responsible for invitations to students with no follow-up as to whether or not they are in the classroom they are in the classroom ? Are institutions simply absolved of any awareness or care of the activities and representations made by third party providers of students in their name ?

In the UK, we saw last year all the screaming when the British government decreed London Metropolitan University (LMU) lost its right to host international fee paying students, due to the claims it has hosted far too much student visa abuse. London Met and many of its institutional colleagues protested loudly. They decried racist government policies to block Asian students, but one never heard LMU own up to its accountability for its own role in abetting visa abuse.

Rather than refer to non-compliance, the Canadian government uses a carrot instead of a stick to encourage institutions to cooperate. The CIC proposal states:
“Institutions whose recruitment practices result in high levels of compliance would also benefit, as visa officers would have access to quantifiable indicators on risk levels to facilitate processing.”

What happens to those who don’t comply and report on their international students is one question. What happens to those institutions found to have significant no-shows and connections to student visa abuse is another.

Perhaps a more fundamental query is will the Canadian government have the actual teeth to
implement and insist upon its call for accountability, where historically there never has been.

1 comment

#1danjoecosMay 10, 2013, 7:53 am

A note on the ” teeth” of the Canadian government: the one solid job offer that I did get in Canada over my past fourteen months looking for work here was rescinded two days later. Apparently the Indian students expected for the summer term to take my classes in business management were seeing a forty percent rejection rate at the Canadian Embassy. Whatever “teeth” the Canadian government assumes to have were pulled directly out of my jaw as the summer term was completely cancelled as a result. Thanks DFAIT.

Add your comment


7 + 8 =

Other articlesgo to homepage

EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS – YOU’RE LIKELY BREAKING THE LAW ……. Commentary from Cathryn Sawicki, Immigration and Citizenship Law

EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS – YOU’RE LIKELY BREAKING THE LAW ……. Commentary from Cathryn Sawicki, Immigration and Citizenship Law(0)

Any educational institution, private or public, that assists int’l students with their immigration documentation is likely breaking the law. Many educational institutions employ “student advisors” at their schools, and “agents” abroad, and as most of these people are unauthorized representatives, this is against the law. You will note that this law has been in effect

Canada at NAFSA. High marks for appearance, not so much for attendance.

Canada at NAFSA. High marks for appearance, not so much for attendance.(0)

Despite an impressive Canadian federal government presence, the annual NAFSA conference in St. Louis from May 27 to 30th, was not particularly well-attended by Canadian delegates. “I was presenting to a delegation from Australia which was part of an estimated 80 strong group, most of whom had travelled trans-Pacific to come,” said Dani Zaretsky, of

Will CIC’s new student visa timelines be competitive ?

Will CIC’s new student visa timelines be competitive ?(0)

CIC’s new guidelines to help avoid delays in visa processing have useful tips for students. Still, how to digest such language as “it is always a good idea to apply as early as possible, and at least four to six months prior to the start of classes”. Might some of the actual time processing frameworks

Canada to crack down on fake varsities luring foreigners

Canada to crack down on fake varsities luring foreigners(0)

(From the Hindustan Times, India) The Canadian government will soon crack down on private institutions of higher learning that mislead international students, including many from India, into enrolling for expensive courses. New regulatory changes proposed by Citizenship and Immigration Canada or CIC in the International Student Programme are aimed at limiting study permits to institutions

Misled to Manitoba

Misled to Manitoba(2)

The CBC report exposing the misleading of international students by the International College of Manitoba (ICM) and its overseas education agent is common. Here the University of Manitoba enabled a network of unknown and uncertain education agents to market with its name, trademarks, brand and reputation. There should be no surprise at the University of

read more

Other sites from the publishers

zi xiu tang
Website by Site Nova
© Copyright 2012 Overseas Overwhelmed All rights reserved.

Warning: include(img/settings.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /u/m/mdbazaar/ on line 84

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening 'img/settings.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:') in /u/m/mdbazaar/ on line 84